SpN 8X09 my off the cuff first reaction

[roxy]

I'm a Dean girl, always have been, even though I don't make a big deal about it. What a douche. I'm going to take a deep breath, do a little woosah. No, fuck that, where does he get *off* with that shit? This is the first time I've ever thought that he made a call that was totally, completely wrong. In seven seasons, he's been a jerk, but let's face it, he's always been right. Not tonight. That was harsh, that was mean, and that was totally self-serving. Trust me, I know very well from self-serving dickery and that was a prime example. He *knew* that was going to hurt. Boy, Dean never forgets and only half-forgives, hunh? How is Sam supposed to come back from that? How are they asking us to *forget* about that? Sam paid all the penance he needs to pay, *all* of it. Anything he did wrong, and don't tell me he wasn't a fucking bitch to Dean with Ruby and the seals and whatnot, he was--but he paid for that. He's got a clean slate. But Dean...*holds up hands* I can't even think right now.

Comments

[roxymissrose.livejournal.com]

. I'm sure he doesn't know the extent of Sam and Amelia's relationship because Sam doesn't seem like he's in a sharing mood with Dean and Dean hasn't seen the soft focus fashback-a-rama, but that was still really mean.

Now that I've chilled a bit, I have to agree with you. There's no reason to assume that Dean knew how Sam truly felt about Amelia--he's probably comparing Sam's relationship to Lisa and his. Because sorry, there's no way in the world anyone can convince me that he thought that was a lifetime love, not when he chose Sam over her.